These are just sketches of points I put together while reading Sigmund Freud’s essay On Dreams. If some points are not coherent it would be best to read the original texts. Or refer to video.
Freud mentions 2 types of content of a dream:
- “manifest content” = the dream that is remembered.
- “latent content ” = the relevant material discovered by analysing the dream.
What is the psychical process which has transformed the latent content to the manifest one which is known to me from my memory?
- What is/are the motive(s) which made this transformation necessary?
I am not convinced that latent content discovered by analysing the dream (A) is the same as the latent content that created the dream’s manifest content (B). Not convinced that we can trust our memory of dreams in the first place.
Aim to describe process in which
- latent content –> manifest content (dream work)
- manifest content –>latent content (analysis)
- problems arising out of dreams: origin of the material, meaning, function of dreaming, why dreams are forgotten.
Latent dream thoughts
THIS deserves attention because it is psychical material changed over from one mode of expression to another.
We come to understand it with guidance and effort.
Understanding it is a function of mental activity.
3 categories of dreams
- dreams that make sense and intelligible.
- have clear sense, but have a bewildering effect.
- withoug intelligibility, seems disconnected, confused and meaningless.
Methinks this is not so clear cut…
Freud considers the contrast between manifest and latent content of 2 and 3rd category dreams of significance. There we are faced by riddles that only disappear after we replace manifest dream by latent thoughts behind it.
Motives that prevented from becoming fully acquainted with the latent dream-thoughts. “A repetition of similar experiences may lead us to suspect that there is an intimate and regular relation between
- the unintelligible and confused nature of dreams and
- the difficulty of reporting the thoughts behind them. “
maybe difficult because it is not possible, not because don’t want… like we cannot remember stuff when 2 yrs old because we dont want or we cannot?
Children’s Dreams (Infantile Dreams)
That children’s dreams are significant but not puzzing is evidence that dreams arent originated from disociated cerebral activity during sleep. p. 663-664.
case 1. girl sick from eating strawberries, and put on fast –> had dreams of eating a meal strawberries.
case 2. boy dreams of feast which he was denied, cherries he wanted to eat himself.
Case studies indicate that children fulfill un-met desires in their dreams.
Dreams were simple an “undisguised fulfillments.”
fulfillment dream in adult, e.g. stimulus of theirs, leads to dreams of drinking, as an attempt to enable continuation of the sleep.
Like in my case dreaming of having woken up, and dressing up when the alarm rang.
Freud describes this too as “dream of convenience”.
Or a dream before a journey of having arrived at the destination and anticipating the pleasure/ expectation of that journey’s destination.
A dream of a woman that their period had started, as interpreted that wish for pregnancy to be postponed.
Even in infantile dream, there is transformation of a sort: a thought expressed in the optative (wishful mood) has been replaced by a representation in the present tense.
- Company at table or table d’hote — spinach dish — Frau E.L.
- Frau E. L. turns attention towards Freud, lays hand on his knee in intimate manner
- Freud removes her hand.
- “but you have such beautiful eyes” she says,
- Freud has distinct picture of drawing of 2 eyes or like outline of spectacles.
Company at table or table d’hote — spinach dish — Frau E.L. :
.A1 Day before after party with he and friend took cab with taximeter. Friend paid the fare, and Freud got trip “free of costs” ( this is the dream instigator). Freud’s preoccupation with being overcharged by looking at taximeter, getting the worst of the bargain. at table d’hote he feels of getting too little. He must keep eye on won interest.
.A2 Few weeks before, at a resort, Freud was annoyed that his wife paid too much attention to some people whose aquaintence Freud himself was not keen to have. He asked her to give him more attention.
A2 The experience was disagreeable, but the dream was the opposite, but not more suitable version of”wish fulfilled”.
A3 Spinach is what his children dont eat and their mother says, just kosten.
Frau E. L. turns attention towards Freud, lays hand on his knee in intimate manner
.B1 Freud was once in debt to Frau E.L.’s father.
.B2 Freud’s engagement
.B3 “Under the table”.
Freud removes her hand.
“But you have such beautiful eyes” she says.
.D1 Freud thinks this has to do with others implying that he gets things from others easily “for the sake of your beautiful eyes“. Freud claims that this is the contrary.
D some part of this is a wish fulfilment, another, a bitter revelation that he never got anything for free. “I would like to get something sometimes without cost Kosten.” p.650
.D Freud remembers later of having, without hesitation, given large sum of money to a relative he was fond of. He remembered giving this relative a ride on a cab. He realises “I wish I might for once experience love that cost me nothing”. Freud later on comes to terms with having regretted giving the money. p. 672 illustrating repression.
Freud has distinct picture of drawing of 2 eyes or like outline of spectacles.
Freud points out the large scale compression or condensation of the ideation in a dream. Every element seems to branch out into 2 or more directions (experiences or impressions). Often these elements contradict each other. Better to take each contradictory element as a stand alone starting points for a series of associations.
Freud believes that if the dream thoughts do not have anything in common, it is possible to create a common representation in the dream-work, there is altering the verbal form, (like creating rhymes).
- Create intermediate thoughts to form a link. like “kosten”.
- Collective and composite figures
- Composit features of 2 people
- or form of one and name of another
- visual picture of one, but situation appropriate to another
- has meaning, of “and” and “just as” to compare the 2 persons
In short, our minds try to make sense of the pieces by building pictures.
Common element(s) can only be discovered by analysis. … but there’s something like an ah-hah moment, right? that is not analysis.
Condensation in dreams therefore means each element is over represented, transformed , dramatized. p. 653
Complicated and Confused Dreams
These dreams have more than condensation and dramatization
The dream content must (after analysis) play subordinate role among the dream thoughts.
“in the course of the dream-work the psychical intensity passes over from the thoughts and ideas to which it prpoerly belongs on to others which in our judgement have no claim to any such emphasis.”
Means what? that the content work to conceal actual thoughts and ideas by making confusing?
“dream displacent” : where psychical intensity, significance or affective pontiality of the though is transformed into sensory vividness.
most distinct manifest content is often not the most important.
e.g. in Freud’s example, what seems to be a woman’s advances, is really a wish to enjoy unselfish love which “costs nothing” behind “beautiful eyes” and spinach. ..
Instigators of dreams — impression
Connection to waking life.
Any dream goes back to impression of few days passed. the impression is important and significant part of waking life.
If connection is found in the content of the dream with any impression of the previous day, that impression is trivial insignificant and unmemorable, that is is difficult to recall.
such cases the content of the dream itself seems to be concerned with indifferent trivialities, unworthy of interest. Freud thinks there is more to these kinds of dreams.
Indifferent impression is an instigator, and analysis brings to light what is significant. There are associative links and associative paths to be discovered.
Dream instigator in Freud’s dream is when his taxi ride from friend was “free of cost”. this contrast with the table d’hote.
Few days earlier before dream, Freud had paid out a considerable sum of money to a family member he was fond of. “free of cost”, out of love. Love that is free of cost stood in forefront of the dream thought.
Dream instigator must always be a recent impression, derived from the dream-day.
Condensation and displacement combine to produce dream displacement.
Inability to recognize dream thoughts
is chiefly caused by displacement. We have to understand the reason for their distortion.
Manifest content is mostly pictoral, metaphorical, symbolic.
Psychical material of dream thoughts includes recollections of impressive experiences like early childhood material… repeated, modified.
There’s also disconnected fragments of visual images, speeches, unmodified thoughts
Dream thoughts derived from anaylsis:
psychical complex that is intricate in structure.
represent foreground, background, conditions, digressions chains of evidence, counter arguments, illustrations… everything clash together? like when on LSD? Aldoxus Huxley 🙂
Material becomes unfamiliar –> regression. Whole materials –> single situation
They produce logical connection by approximation in time and space. Yup. LSD…
All dreams produced on a single night wil be found on analysis to be derived from the same circle of thougths… or could this rather be that during analysis there is a thought process which interpretes everything that way?
Causal relation between 2 thoughts
- unrepresented or
- replaced by a sequence of 2 pieces of dreams of different lengths.
representation is often reversed: begining of the dream stands for the consequence, and conclusion is the premise.
transformation of e.g. A to B represents the cause and effect.
“either … or” never expressed in dreams. usually both will be represented as equally valid.
Contrarian ideas expressed as one and the same element. “No” seems not to exist in dreams.
Opposition between 2 thoughts, the relation of reversal, may be represented in dreams: represented by some other piece of dream-content being turned into its opposite — an afterthought. the sensation of inhibition of movement serves to express a conflict of will.
Similarity consonance, the possession of common attributes — highly favored mechanism of dream-formation.
Dream-work makes use of agreement to form a kind of unity.
Absurdity in a dream signifies the presence in the dream-thoughts of contradiction, redicule and derision. Hence dreams are not uncritical dissociated mental acitivity.
no dream is prompted by motives other than egoistic ones.? me not smart enough for this.
of psychical material there is
- pictoral arrangement
+ PLUS there is to consider, dream composition.
Only comes into operation AFTER the dream content has already been constructed.
Functions to arrange constituents of the dream to make it a composed whole.
Considerations of intelligibility —> final revision of the dream (dream facades)
to make sense of the senseless.
wishful phantasies — modified versions of scenes from infancy
dream work is not creative, develops no own phantasies, makes no judgements and draws no colnlusion– no function other than condensation and displacement of material into puctorial form and a bit intepretive revision.
The Psychical Mechanism of dreams is analagous to other phenomena like forgetting, slips of tongue, bungled action… (Freud’s Pathology of Everyday life).
Displacement is the heart of the problem, of which lies a motive. The need to conceal content that is disagreeable. Repression.
There is a causal connection between the obscurity of the dream content and the state of repression of certain dream-thoughts hence there is ‘dream-distortion’.
Dreams are disguised fullfilments of repressed wishes.
3 Classes in Wish-Fullfilment in Dreams
- Unrepressed wish is represented openly
- Repressed wish is represented in disguise: Anxiety is only avoided owing to the dream-work.
- Repressed wish is represented openly, or little disguise:
these are accompanied by anxiety which interrupts them. Anxiety takes the place of “dream-distortion”.
Repressed wishes when they surface is a cause for anxiety.
Clear dreams with distressing content which is not felt distressing in the dream itself. They cannot be counted as anxiety dreams… these have psychical value.
2 Thought-Constructing Agencies
activity is unconscious and can only reach consciousness by way of products(?)
- has free access of consciousness for its products
Censorship between conscious and unconscious.
Repression is relaxation of censorship –> formation fo a compromise.
When sleep is over, censorship takes place and hence we forget dreams or remember fragments of dreams. p.677
Dreams as Guardians of Sleep
keep internal mental stimuli from disturbing sleep
Relax mental energy required to hold down repressed material during the day.
Dream may be used to prevent external stimuli from disturbing sleep.
Manifest content which show no sexual material are revealed to have sexual wish-fulfilments.
Mode of representation is described as symbols of the things they represent.
What happens to people who know what the symbols mean? do they stop dreamnig these symbols because now the repressed wishes are clearly reflected, because the symbols no longer hide anything? what symbols do these wishes then change to? What is someone dreams of a tree because he just bought a tree?
Freud, S., & Strachey, J. (1952). On dreams (No. 144). WW Norton & Company.